Have you ever read a review that you really didn't agree with? How about a cover story that seemed completely unnecessary and overloaded with praise for features that seemed... lacking? Has a magazine and/or website ever seemed biased towards a specific group or console? Most of the time this results from a difference in opinion; different gamers breed different tastes, after all. Nine times out of ten, when someone accuses a publication of unjustified bias, it's based on false presumptions.
But, one time out of ten, they're absolutely right.
By: Karl Castaneda
When David Jaffe, of Sony - Santa Monica fame, accused game journalism of being lackluster this past November, I was with him 50%. On one hand, he's definitely right that game journalism doesn't have a Rolling Stone (or even an Entertainment Weekly, to be quite honest). But there's a reason for it: the game industry is too closed off to allow the full coverage you get from the aforementioned two magazines. So you see, the media is stuck between a rock and a hard place: they want great coverage, but they're limited only to what publishers want consumers to know.
And you know what? Up until recently, I thought that this was the only problem with game journalism. How wrong I was...
You all probably don't know who Dan Hsu is, but you definitely know what magazine he runs: Electronic Gaming Monthly. Your personal thoughts of the periodical aside, Hsu's always been a pretty level-headed guy and a solid game journalist, which is probably why he was so disgusted with the parasite he lifted the veil off of in his latest op-ed, entitled Editorial Integrity. In it, Hsu described the following:
"I was a little suspicious of the cover choices one of our competitors was making, so I checked in with a contact of mine from a major game publisher. "Yes," he confirmed. "We can pretty much get whatever cover we want from that magazine. All it takes is for us to meet with the publisher, promise that we'll buy some ads, and discuss the details from there." So...that magazine's cover stories are for sale. Great.
Recently, some publicists for another game company were lamenting the fact that they couldn't get any coverage on a certain, very high-profile website out there, because they weren't advertising with that site. To get stories written up on their games, they'd have to start spending the bucks. More editorial coverage for sale. Wonderful."
Yeah, I was pissed, but I wasn't that surprised.
A couple months ago, a friend of mine recieved a certain movie tie-in game that wasn't doing very well among the game media, especially on its DS version (which was what he was reviewing). It was a crappy game and he scored it accordingly. Much to his (and my) surprise, he received an email from the very developer he had just finished criticizing. In the letter, there was a plea to change the score, for if this game did not meet with at least a 70% on Game Rankings, they would lose their support from the publisher.
Naturally, my friend rejected this idea since it was, you know, wrong (and because it was a developer and not a publisher, the outlet wouldn't have to worry about a backlash), but unfortunately for you guys, this kind of thing happens pretty often. Remember GameSpy's Donkey Konga 2 incident? If you don't, a freelance journalist doing a review for GameSpy (guess which game it was!) blew the door open on GS's review practices when he publicly stated that they had changed the game's score from it's original one and a half stars to a full three stars. Hm... I wonder why...
By now you're probably wondering how all of this can happen. Why are these self-proclaimed "dignified journalists" behaving in a manner so unbecoming and insulting to the field they represent? Well, I'm going to let you guys in on a little fact: being a publication without support sucks. Nobody buys your ad space, leaving you with virtually zero cash to pay your employees, purchase games and peripherals to aid coverage, and even keep up with the maintenance bills. So put yourself in Joe Reviewer's situation. They can be either be heroes and have the bank foreclose on their house or they can bite their pride and keep food on their family's table. This doesn't make it right, but in a world where mags go under every day, do they have much choice?
Hsu says in his article that EGM's big enough to speak out against this problem and not worry about the consequences, but I think it's time he wakes up and looks at the real world. If he really had taken off the kid gloves, he wouldn't keep everything anonymous. He'd have said exactly what needed to be said. But he didn't because there would be serious consequences. People would lose their jobs; EGM would find an assload of trouble on their doorstep, that's for sure. No one, and I mean no one, has the balls to tell EA to go take its money hat and shove it up their collective ass. Sure, not every outlet out there is crooked; a lot of them are honest folk; but to think that they've got complete control over what they print is ludicrous.
R.I.P. Game Journalism?
There are a lot of future game journalists on this forum. Zach, Matt, Josh, Mike, you guys know who you are. What will you do when you get to your dreams only to find out that you're writing someone else's opinion; what will you do when your keyboard is just the middleman between a faxed-in review and the gaming public? Will you stand up and fight or will you keep your job? It's a tough question.
But maybe, just maybe, someone will climb the ranks high enough where they can be the Rolling Stone of video games. Maybe someone's magazine can be so rich in content that they'll always have a readership, publisher support or not, since their company name is so well-known among the mainstream that they can survive based on ads by non-game products. Maybe someone can give the finger to the pusher-man one day. And when that day comes, future reviewers of America, will you defend the ideal that made you a journalist in the first place, or will you be so jaded that you'll shrug off such a revolution? It's your choice.
But if you ask me, game journalism ain't dead yet, mutha fucka.
A lot of interest for your blog and a great deal of discussion. Great sites to surf xbox 360 premium gold pack, domain name, domain reseller, au domain, free website, online business, home based business, electric scooter, xbox360!
Very nice site.
kinetic photo [URL=http://kinetic.xbuv.info/]kinetic[/URL] news http://kinetic.xbuv.info/ kinetic video
[b][url="http://hydrocodone.dewall.info "]hydrocodone side effects[/url][/b]
olympus digital camera
digital camera sale
sony digital camera dsc
digital camera review hp
Enjoyed the blog about tracker wii found it very informative. I found a good website which also features tracker wii and tracker wii. The link is great for **uk bargains** including Nintendo Wii, PS2, PS3, games consoles and features famous online stores inc Argos, Marks and Spencer, Empire Direct, LX Direct, Tesco, Next. There is also a chance to play online bingo and try your luck at the online gambling sites available inc roulette, poker and fruit machines. I've also found another site for **free soccer links**. Hope you find these sites interesting - all the best!
Good blog - very interesting!! Thought you might like some excellent advice on driving extra traffic to your website/blog - I'm into advertising gambling online and to drive traffic to my website I was searching around the internet for absolutely ages looking for SEO tools to fire my site up the Google search engine, then I signed up free for this superb traffic gereating tool - I now have loads of hits to my websites/blogs and my site is shooting up the Google rankings quicker than ever before.
Consequently this can see your affiliate commissions shoot through the roof - meaning lots of extra money coming in for you and your family. Sign up now - it's free.. Sorry if this information is of no use to you but seeing as you have the anonymous feature enabled I thought I should share this free bit of essential promotional advice with you and would hope you would do the same for me.
I hope the tool will serve you equally as well as it has me!!
Best of luck, cheers for now, dave.
Classifieds for our community. Buy, sell, trade, date, events... post anything. Adquity Classifieds.
Post a Comment